Formaggio Kitchen Mustard Club

Calling All Mustard Lovers!

There's a whole world of mustard out there, from French Dijon mustard to English hot mustard. This club is perfect for a mustard lover who's looking to experience different flavors and textures of mustards from around the world. 

Gifting the Club?

We’ve made it easy to gift the membership to any mustard lover in your life. You can purchase an ongoing membership that can be cancelled at any time or pre-pay for a full year. You also can provide a gift message and/or their email address for us to contact them about the membership.

What's Included

Every 3 months you'll get (you'll receive 4 packages a year, one in January, April, July, and October):

  • A selection of 3-4 jars of mustard (get access to exclusive flavors not available for retail!)
  • Access to a landing page, updated monthly, where you can learn about each one

Member benefits:

  • Free shipping on each quarter's shipment
  • Free shipping for any items added onto the quarterly subscription
  • Special surprises and bonuses for our long term subscribers

3rd Quarter 2026 Selection

New to the Shop

This quarter we’re highlighting a selection of brand new mustards that just hit our shelves.

Moutarde Pommery Moutarde de Meaux

This mustard was the Grand Champion of the 2026 World-Wide Mustard Competition. This is a traditional stone-ground French mustard crafted from a recipe that dates back to the 1700s. It is a vinegary coarse mustard that goes well with any meat dish.

Raye's Sea Smoke Mustard

Raye’s, which has been family-run and based in Maine for over 125 years, is the last remaining stone mustard mill in America. This unique flavored mustard from them, ‘Sea Smoke,’ brings a unique blend that’s not just smoky but also balanced with sweetness and a touch of heat. The complex flavor profile makes it versatile and memorable, pairing well with everything from grilled meats to roasted vegetables.

Schwerter Senfmuhle Curry Mustard

This German mustard is produced at one of the oldest traditional mustard mills in Germany. The mill is owned and operated by Frank Peisert, who works with the finest mustard seeds available. Through a double-milling process he creates smooth yet subtly grainy mustards. This new flavor from Schwerter is made with the addition of vibrant curry powder, giving it a warm flavor from the spice blend. A must on any German-style sausage!

Organic Karashi Mustard Powder

Yamasei's Japanese mustard powder is made from stone ground organic Barukan (Vulcan in English) mustard seeds. As you might gather from the Oni (Demon) on the packaging, this karashi is very spicy yet still has the most mustardy taste. To retain the mustard flavor, Yamasei takes great care when removing the oil and grinding the seeds to a paste. How to use: Thoroughly mix 4 parts mustard powder with 5 parts lukewarm water (between 104℉ and 140℉). Allow the mustard paste to rest between 5 and 15 minutes to develop the spicy taste. Add to potato salad, cucumbers, or use as a condiment alongside pork belly or katsu.

Next Shipment Date

Q3: Wednesday, July 8th, 2026

Q4: Wednesday, October 14th, 2026

FAQs

The membership is $60 per quarter. You can purchase a recurring membership where you will be billed quarterly or pre-pay 1 year which will not renew.

Making changes to your subscription is easy. Just log on to your Formaggio Kitchen account and hit “Manage Subscriptions.” There you will find options to change your delivery address, skip a month, cancel your subscription, and/or update your billing information.

We ship out the quarterly club packages the 2nd Wednesday of the first month of each quarter. While we can’t accommodate a custom ship date, you can skip a shipment by logging into your Formaggio Kitchen account.

Our quarterly club packages ship the 2nd Wednesday of each January, April, July, and October. If you purchase mid-quarter your first shipment will be shipped the following quarter.

Your shipment will arrive the 2nd full week of the 1st month of each quarter.

While we can’t customize what comes in the quarterly selection, as a member you can add whatever products you’d like to take advantage of the free shipping that comes with your membership. Purchase additional items through the club portal and we’ll consolidate it all into one box to be shipped the first full week of the month.

Yes. If you don’t want all your items to be consolidated into one shipment you’ll need to place a separate order. Please note that in order to take advantage of your free shipping as a member all items must be consolidated into the monthly club shipment.

You can reach our team at orders@formaggiokitchen.com with any questions or concerns.

Yes, you can skip a package and/or change your shipping address by logging into your Formaggio Kitchen account.

Mustards have a long shelf life unopened. Once opened, we recommend storing them in the fridge and enjoying within 6 months.

If you’re using our prepaid option you can apply a gift card to your purchase. However, unfortunately, we can’t take gift card payments for our quarterly recurring memberships just yet.

Orders must be placed the Sunday before the 2nd full week of the 1st month of each quarter in order to be added to your shipment.

Yes! You can gift a recurring subscription or pre-pay for a year.