My Account

Hinman Settler Vermont Blue Cheese


Another winner from Jasper Hill Farm, the addition of raw sheep's milk takes this relative of Bayley Hazen to the next level. 

Subtotal -
Shipping Details

To keep this perishable product at its best, expedited shipping is required

Email Email
Details Arrow down


At Jasper Hill Farm in the northeast corner of Vermont, the Kehler family is busy every day making some of America's best quality farmstead cheeses. The milk from their roughly 40 Ayrshire cows is distinctly sweet with some toasted nut flavors, and each of their cheeses is bursting with these bold aromas.

Hinman Settler is sister to Jasper Hill's Bayley Hazen, an award-winning blue cheese well established in their lineup. Hinman Settler adds a measure of raw sheep's milk to up the creaminess of Bayley Hazen's usual balanced earthy and fudgey profile. 

More Information Arrow down
Region Vermont
Country of Origin United States
Producer Jasper Hill Farm
Cheese Type Blue
Type of Milk Mixed Milk
Flavor Profile Strong
Beer Pairings Brown Ale, Porter, Stout
Wine Pairings Dessert Wine, Port
Care & Use Arrow down

Serving and Caring for your cheese

Caring for Your Cheese

How much cheese should I buy?

We advise buying small quantities more frequently to avoid long term storage because the complex flavors and aromas of good cheese will change and degrade over time. For appetizer quantities and not much left over, we suggest 1/4 lb per person. For larger servings or if you'd like some left overs, we suggest a full 1/2 lb per person.

How should I serve my cheese?

You can serve any number of cheeses: a single magnificent chèvre or a large selection celebrating the diversity of aromas, flavors and textures found in various traditions around the world. Choose what you like and what you expect your audience will enjoy. We usually go for a selection of three to four cheeses with various milk types, textures and flavors.

Take your cheese out of the refrigerator an hour or so before serving. Just before serving, unwrap each cheese and scrape the cut surface with a knife edge to remove a thin layer. If you notice dried out parts or mold on the face of the cheese, cut it away.

Can I eat the rind?

Most cheeses have rinds and most rinds are edible. If you don’t like the taste or texture, cut it off.

What do I do about the mold on my cheese?

Cheese stored for some time may grow exterior molds. Typical molds will be white or blue-green but you can sometimes come across yellow or gray. Most of the time, you can refresh the cheese by cutting away those affected areas. The cheese underneath will be fine.

How do I store my cheese?

Store in a higher humidity area of your refrigerator - likely an enclosed spot which allows for limited airflow rather than constant drafts.

How do I wrap my cheese?

Use a clean wrap of the cheese paper, or, in a pinch use parchment (for softer cheeses) or aluminum foil (for firm to hard cheeses).


Reviews Arrow down

Add your review Hinman Settler Vermont Blue Cheese

Your Rating
Please select one of each of the ratings above.